Hands down AMAZINGLY GOOD! If you're looking for the best steak of your life, the Rusty Barrel Supper Club is more than worth the drive. From the moment you arrive, the experience is special. You enter through a back alley and ring a doorbell to get in, which immediately transports you to a classic, prohibition-era speakeasy. The vibe inside is intimate and cozy, with a fantastic atmosphere that feels like a hidden secret you're glad you discovered. Of course, the star of the show is the steak. This place makes the best steaks I've ever had. My ribeye was perfectly marbled, with a smoky, buttery flavor that melted in my mouth. The meal is made even better by the legendary salad bar, which is included with every entree. It’s fresh, crisp, and has a great variety of toppings to build the perfect side. It’s definitely a standout feature and a highlight of the meal. The service was also top-notch. Our server was friendly, attentive, and made the entire experience feel welcoming and smooth. It’s the kind of service that makes you feel like a valued guest. We will definitely be back for another unforgettable meal!!!
Rusty Barrell Supper Club Inc
Excerpts
Hands down AMAZINGLY GOOD! If you're looking for the best steak of your life, the Rusty Barrel Supper Club is more than worth the drive. From the moment you arrive, the experience is special. You enter through a back alley and ring a doorbell to get in, which immediately transports you to a classic, prohibition-era speakeasy. The vibe inside is intimate and cozy, with a fantastic atmosphere that feels like a hidden secret you're glad you discovered. Of course, the star of the show is the steak. This place makes the best steaks I've ever had. My ribeye was perfectly marbled, with a smoky, buttery flavor that melted in my mouth. The meal is made even better by the legendary salad bar, which is included with every entree. It’s fresh, crisp, and has a great variety of toppings to build the perfect side. It’s definitely a standout feature and a highlight of the meal. The service was also top-notch. Our server was friendly, attentive, and made the entire experience feel welcoming and smooth. It’s the kind of service that makes you feel like a valued guest. We will definitely be back for another unforgettable meal!!!
A staple of Oklahoma steakhouses. Grilled to perfection in the center of the main dining room, the marinade on the meat sets them miles apart from their nearest competitor. Worth the drive wherever you are coming in from. - The ribeye has always stood out, always great marbling and flavor (not taking anything away from the filet or kc strip) - sides, salad bar, bread - enjoyable but the meat is the star of the show - tuxedo cake for dessert is excellent. Staff and ambience- fantastic. The addition of the great bar/lounge adds so much and takes nothing away from the original charm. 10/10
A staple of Oklahoma steakhouses. Grilled to perfection in the center of the main dining room, the marinade on the meat sets them miles apart from their nearest competitor. Worth the drive wherever you are coming in from. - The ribeye has always stood out, always great marbling and flavor (not taking anything away from the filet or kc strip) - sides, salad bar, bread - enjoyable but the meat is the star of the show - tuxedo cake for dessert is excellent. Staff and ambience- fantastic. The addition of the great bar/lounge adds so much and takes nothing away from the original charm. 10/10
We were traveling from WI to Texas and made our overnight stop in the town and had the best experience. First you walk between two buildings and have to hit a buzzer, giving it a true speakeasy feeling. The food was beyond wonderful and our waitress Jessi was fantastic. She had put my order in wrong and she was so wonderful and honest about it. Absolutely worth the drive off the interstate.