EDIT: Changing my review from 3 stars to 5. Brent actually reached out to me (after I totally missed their original response - oops) because he genuinely cares about the business and their consistency. He explained that they always want the chance to fix things in the moment, and honestly, that’s on me for not calling the store when my order wasn’t quite right. This man showed great pride in this place. You don’t chase down a random reviewer unless you really want customers to have a great experience. That level of dedication means a lot. If you’ve never tried them, try them. I’ll update my photos after my next order - stay tuned for the pizza glamour shots. ************* Overall, this is a good pizza place. My very first order was so good that I wondered if it might become my new favorite - especially the dunkers and the cinnamon dessert pizza, which were both incredible. Since then, though, the consistency just hasn’t been the same. I’ve placed five or more orders, and only one came close to that first experience. The others fell a bit short - sometimes the dunkers were overly buttery, and other times the cinnamon dessert pizza was missing its cinnamon and icing despite paying for extra, leaving it closer to plain dough with streusel. Service has always been solid. Ordering online is easy, though not fast if you’re in a rush. The atmosphere is what you’d expect from a classic neighborhood pizza spot. Because of the cost on me as a customer for the inconsistency, I’m not sure I’ll keep ordering. I’ve included photos from my most recent order for context.
Buffalo Pizza
Excerpts
EDIT: Changing my review from 3 stars to 5. Brent actually reached out to me (after I totally missed their original response - oops) because he genuinely cares about the business and their consistency. He explained that they always want the chance to fix things in the moment, and honestly, that’s on me for not calling the store when my order wasn’t quite right. This man showed great pride in this place. You don’t chase down a random reviewer unless you really want customers to have a great experience. That level of dedication means a lot. If you’ve never tried them, try them. I’ll update my photos after my next order - stay tuned for the pizza glamour shots. ************* Overall, this is a good pizza place. My very first order was so good that I wondered if it might become my new favorite - especially the dunkers and the cinnamon dessert pizza, which were both incredible. Since then, though, the consistency just hasn’t been the same. I’ve placed five or more orders, and only one came close to that first experience. The others fell a bit short - sometimes the dunkers were overly buttery, and other times the cinnamon dessert pizza was missing its cinnamon and icing despite paying for extra, leaving it closer to plain dough with streusel. Service has always been solid. Ordering online is easy, though not fast if you’re in a rush. The atmosphere is what you’d expect from a classic neighborhood pizza spot. Because of the cost on me as a customer for the inconsistency, I’m not sure I’ll keep ordering. I’ve included photos from my most recent order for context.
There is a lack of good pizza in the area, so these guys are a godsend. I order pretty much weekly and they always have your order done timely and it always feels like it just came out the oven and wasn't sitting around getting cold like at some other places. I really like the Pulaski (pan pizza), and the Cinnamon dessert sticks, but honestly have not had a bad item here, my wife loves the wings. I used to order here around when they first opened, and I'll tell you if you didn't love it then, try it now. They've really improved over time, and you can tell the owner & employees care about putting out a good product and taking care of the customers. 10/10
There is a lack of good pizza in the area, so these guys are a godsend. I order pretty much weekly and they always have your order done timely and it always feels like it just came out the oven and wasn't sitting around getting cold like at some other places. I really like the Pulaski (pan pizza), and the Cinnamon dessert sticks, but honestly have not had a bad item here, my wife loves the wings. I used to order here around when they first opened, and I'll tell you if you didn't love it then, try it now. They've really improved over time, and you can tell the owner & employees care about putting out a good product and taking care of the customers. 10/10
The pizza and wings never disappoint! This is our go-to pizza place. The pizza is not anything extravagant but it’s exactly what to want on a Friday night. The garlic parmesan wings are so delicious!