Eureka Eatery

I had heard good things about this restaurant before deciding to check it out. What I didn’t know ahead of time was it was in the back of a convenience store/gas station. Even though we were looking for a place to sit and eat we decided to try it anyway and I’m glad we did! There were a few tables so we were able to sit and eat which was great but again it was the back of a convenience store/gas station so while it was clean the atmosphere was as you would expect. Everything improved greatly from there. It was busy with most of the customers getting their food to go but the line moved quickly and the order came out quickly as well. The service was amazing! Super friendly, knowledgeable and accommodating. The person taking our order even asked how much ice we wanted in our drinks. I ordered a chicken tenders and fries and my husband ordered the medium hot chicken tenders and fries. It was delicious! Everything was piping hot and fresh. Really one of the best orders of tenders I have ever had. My husband said his was definitely spicy and also good. Fries were hot and crisp. I would recommend this place but better to plan your get a to go order as seating is very limited and right in the middle of the line to order and the line to pick up. But do pick up an order to go!

I had heard good things about this restaurant before deciding to check it out. What I didn’t know ahead of time was it was in the back of a convenience store/gas station. Even though we were looking for a place to sit and eat we decided to try it anyway and I’m glad we did! There were a few tables so we were able to sit and eat which was great but again it was the back of a convenience store/gas station so while it was clean the atmosphere was as you would expect. Everything improved greatly from there. It was busy with most of the customers getting their food to go but the line moved quickly and the order came out quickly as well. The service was amazing! Super friendly, knowledgeable and accommodating. The person taking our order even asked how much ice we wanted in our drinks. I ordered a chicken tenders and fries and my husband ordered the medium hot chicken tenders and fries. It was delicious! Everything was piping hot and fresh. Really one of the best orders of tenders I have ever had. My husband said his was definitely spicy and also good. Fries were hot and crisp. I would recommend this place but better to plan your get a to go order as seating is very limited and right in the middle of the line to order and the line to pick up. But do pick up an order to go!

UPDATE: They changed the whole menu and now all the food is significantly worse and not worth the price anymore. Bring back the waffle fries. Will just be going somewhere else. Got the Deluxe Chicken Sandwich Combo. The pink lemonade wasn't very good, tasted like tea. The toppings on the sandwich looked a bit iffy. Besides that, best fries and ranch out of anywhere I've been. 8/10 will definitely go back.

UPDATE: They changed the whole menu and now all the food is significantly worse and not worth the price anymore. Bring back the waffle fries. Will just be going somewhere else. Got the Deluxe Chicken Sandwich Combo. The pink lemonade wasn't very good, tasted like tea. The toppings on the sandwich looked a bit iffy. Besides that, best fries and ranch out of anywhere I've been. 8/10 will definitely go back.

I had a very disappointing experience at Eureka Eatery tonight (02/25/2026). Their posted closing time is 9:30 PM, and my fiancée and I walked in at 9:03 PM — well before closing. As soon as we entered, a young employee was already stacking chairs on tables and moving the carpets. When she saw us walk in, she visibly rolled her eyes right at us. My fiancée immediately felt uncomfortable and suggested we leave, but I approached the register to place an order. The attitude we received was extremely rude from the same girl and unprofessional. The employee acted annoyed that we came in during business hours, and her tone and demeanor made it clear we were not welcome. I ended up walking out mid-order because the experience was so unpleasant. If you’re open until 9:30 PM, customers should not be made to feel like an inconvenience at 9:03 PM. Based on this experience, I won’t be returning. Customer service matters, and this was completely unacceptable. She may need to seek therapy