Stefanina's Pizzeria Wentzville

Stefanina's has always been fantastic but I forget about it tucked away in old wentzville. I stopped in for lunch recently and will stop by more often. Stellar service. Fast kitchen. Pizza was perfect. They give you a roll with honey butter with your salad and the creamy italian dressing was superb.

Stefanina's has always been fantastic but I forget about it tucked away in old wentzville. I stopped in for lunch recently and will stop by more often. Stellar service. Fast kitchen. Pizza was perfect. They give you a roll with honey butter with your salad and the creamy italian dressing was superb.

Pizza delivery took longer then usual. Food was cold and in no warmer bag??? 🥶 It's 16 degrees out. Pizza was overcooked and had no sauce on it at all. I Gave them a 2nd chance too redeem themselves. It was the same issue as before 😞 I didn't complain first time cause stuff happens but TWICE now, it's no coincidence... 👎

Pizza delivery took longer then usual. Food was cold and in no warmer bag??? 🥶 It's 16 degrees out. Pizza was overcooked and had no sauce on it at all. I Gave them a 2nd chance too redeem themselves. It was the same issue as before 😞 I didn't complain first time cause stuff happens but TWICE now, it's no coincidence... 👎

I prefer to pickup, but I placed an order for delivery due to having surgery and being unable to pickup. I hadn't eaten in almost 24 hrs and all I was craving was Stef's. Every bit of the "hot" food showed up COMPLETELY COLD. The cheese balls were soggy and rubbery- the sauce that came with them was the hottest (ie-luke warm) thing that came out of all of it. The pizza was so cold & tough it was hard to chew. They were sure to point out that it arrived before the estimated time and they use hot bags, but I have a hard time believing that with how cold everything was. Is the bag full of holes? How long did my order *really* sit in a warmer before they could pair it with another delivery in the area to save themselves some time? Long enough to become completely disgusting, though they assured me it could not have been more than 5 minutes. They offered to remake it but at this point I'm over it. She said they would need to come pickup the first order and bring it back to the store. I did not want to have to wait another hour+ to eat bc they can't deliver food that is at the very least warm- I did not have faith the second order would be any better. I spent over $80 for this order to be terrible- that's a lot of money on such a waste. I used to love this Stef's; we started going here more than a dozen years ago. My last few experiences here have been disappointing, both with staff and food, but this was it. I will never come back to this location.