Me and my family especially my son absolutely loves this place the mozzarella sticks are spot on. Those are his favorites. They are the perfect consistency nice and crunchy on the outside super chewy and delicious on the inside. Clearly the marinara sauce that they use on the pizza and cone with the mozzarella sticks is homemade, fresh & amazing. So good! And the dough/crush for the pizza is delicious. Really good. I like the variety of toppings of the pizza are a nice twist but keeping to the Brooklyn style of pizza. It's both elevated and Artisan yet still very nostalgic and delicious without doing too much.
pizza
The Brooklyn Firefly
· $$$$ · brooklyn · Strict-vegan verified
Fully vegan
Editor synopsis · 0 reviews
Diners overwhelmingly call out the signature dish as the must-order. The vibe reads as pizza — service is consistently described as warm and unhurried. Common gotcha: queues form at peak times — go early or late.
Excerpts
Me and my family especially my son absolutely loves this place the mozzarella sticks are spot on. Those are his favorites. They are the perfect consistency nice and crunchy on the outside super chewy and delicious on the inside. Clearly the marinara sauce that they use on the pizza and cone with the mozzarella sticks is homemade, fresh & amazing. So good! And the dough/crush for the pizza is delicious. Really good. I like the variety of toppings of the pizza are a nice twist but keeping to the Brooklyn style of pizza. It's both elevated and Artisan yet still very nostalgic and delicious without doing too much.
Amazing! The service was impeccable and the food was delicious! The place has a cool vintage atmosphere with live music every now and then.
Amazing! The service was impeccable and the food was delicious! The place has a cool vintage atmosphere with live music every now and then.
Good vegan options, especially for Bay Ridge! Yummy pizza and good beers. Outdoor seating! No step to enter. Large ADA gender neutral restroom July 2025 update : still delicious vegan options!